The Bernoulli Equation
In
the US, many students' first introduction to aerodynamic principles happens in
basic physics or natural sciences coursework with a lesson on the "Bernoulli
effect." Unfortunately, for a lot of people this is also the end of their
education in aerodynamics, leading to a lot of incorrect understanding,
weird theories, and gross oversimplification—like the incorrect idea that a
fully streamlined body with no flow separation will have no pressure drag (it
still does).
You
probably recall the gist of it: as the velocity of a stream of air increases,
its static pressure is reduced. This qualitative relationship is always true of
low speed flows with no energy addition, since (total) pressure is a measure of
the (total) energy in a volume of air and, because energy cannot be created or
destroyed spontaneously, when more of that energy is used in the kinetic energy
of the flow there must be less internal energy (static pressure) available.
![]() |
| This is one explanation of how wings make lift, although it has nothing to do with the "equal transit theorem" that many students are taught (incorrectly). |
…where
k is some constant total pressure. This equation only applies if we make
certain assumptions; specifically, five of them:
1) inviscid flow
2)
incompressible flow
3) irrotational flow
4) negligible body forces
5) steady flow
Only
when
these five conditions are met does the Bernoulli equation apply. This is the
first thing most people get wrong about aerodynamics, assuming that this
relationship holds anywhere in a flow (incorrectly assuming that total pressure
is constant everywhere). It does not, and the first reason it doesn't is
because anywhere we have flow past a body or surface, there will be friction forces acting
on it—so, we cannot assume it is inviscid. We can only neglect viscosity
sufficiently far from a body or wall, outside the boundary layer that develops
along every body submerged in moving air.
The
Bernoulli equation also does not apply to dense fluids like water because their
high mass per volume leads to non-negligible gravitational force (and
introduces changes in potential energy, which is not accounted for in the equation).
However, air has sufficiently low density (even when it contains water vapor,
like clouds) that we can usually approximate the effect of gravity on it as
nonexistent. This applies to small volumes only; if we take something like the
hydrostatic equation and a large column of air (which describes the physical
mechanism that results in the atmospheric pressure we feel at ground level),
gravity is of course not negligible. But looking at a sufficiently small volume
of air—say, the air immediately surrounding your car—the assumption of no body
forces is generally valid.
We
can divide flow conditions over time into steady and unsteady or transient
classifications. The latter mean flow conditions change over time while the
former means the properties of the flow are constant through time. Real flows
are inherently subject to unsteady phenomena like turbulence, which means that
no flow in the real world is truly steady. However, we can approximate a lot of
flow problems as steady if the time interval under consideration is long
enough, taking average properties as characteristic of the flow. This does not
apply all the time, but when it does the Bernoulli equation holds.
That's
three out of five; what about the last two? To explain these, we have to delve
into vector math and how we use it to describe properties of the flow—in particular,
the velocity field.
Velocity
Velocity
is a vector, a composite of elements that define its magnitude and direction.
Vectors can be written in a variety of formats but it is usual when
representing velocity to break it into components along the three physical dimensions
using the letters,
3) irrotational flow
4) negligible body forces
5) steady flow
To
make operations easier to perform, you will frequently see these vectors
transposed, sometimes with a "T" (for "transpose") superscript indicator:
The
gradient operator (sometimes called "grad" or "nabla") is another vector—but different
from ordinary vectors, the elements of this one perform an operation by taking
the partial derivative of another vector or function:
This
tells us the change in velocity with change in position. But this is not the
only operation we can perform using the gradient operator. If we apply it using
other vector relations, it can tell us two important things about the flow—and the
validity of the Bernoulli equation.
Divergence
In
vector math, there are different types of multiplication or products (this arises
from the definition of vector subspaces and something called "closure
properties," which allows for mathematical operations to be defined any way we
want so long as the closure properties are not violated). "Divergence" is
defined by the inner product (or dot product) of the gradient
operator and the velocity:
This
gives a scalar quantity with units s-1 or Hz (hertz).
Divergence
is an important parameter of the flow because it tells us whether the flow is
compressible or incompressible. If the divergence is zero,
then
the volume of a fluid element of mass dm does not change as it traverses
its path along the flow. No volume change of a constant-mass element means
constant density, ρ = c, and the flow is incompressible—one of our
two remaining criteria for application of the Bernoulli equation.
Curl
The "curl" of the velocity is given by another type of multiplication, this time
the cross product of the gradient operator and the velocity. This type
of product outputs another vector orthogonal to both (you may be familiar with torque,
which is the cross product of an applied force and a moment arm):
This
gives a vector with units Hz.
As
you might guess, this tells us something about rotation in the flow—but be
careful! This is not vorticity, which is rotation in the velocity field,
but the change in orientation of the body axes of any infinitesimal element dm
with respect to world coordinates. If the curl is zero,
then
the orientation of any fluid element dm does not change as it traverses
its path along the flow and the flow is irrotational—satisfying the last
criterion for application of the Bernoulli equation.
Velocity
Field
Finally,
if we apply the gradient operator to the velocity vector (the spatial function
above will give the same result when decomposed), then our two vectors expand
into another dimension—so two 1x3 vectors output a 3x3 matrix:
This
gives the change in each component of velocity with change in spatial coordinates
along the x, y, and z axes of whatever space we've
defined. Notice that the center diagonal of this matrix contains the elements in
the divergence of the flow, while the remaining elements, diagonally in the
opposite direction, produce the components of the flow's curl.
Example
So,
why is Bernoulli important? If we can show that a particular flow problem
satisfies the five criteria necessary to be able to apply it, the Bernoulli
equation lets us predict the velocity and static pressure anywhere in the flow.
That's powerful! Aerospace engineers still use it today (as in the first image, a screen capture of an AVL simulation) to predict lift and
aircraft performance with potential flow theory, another centuries-old
body of mathematics. Let's look at a simple example to demonstrate.
Potential
flow theory works by superposing one or more of several basic flows: uniform
flow, sources, sinks, doublets (a combination of source and sink), and vortices.
Defining the potential or stream functions of each of these, combining them in whatever way we want,
and then taking the derivative gives the resulting velocity field. Say we have
uniform horizontal flow from the left and a point vortex of strength Γ
(gamma) at arbitrary coordinate (0, 0) in a plane. The resulting velocity field
is given by:
Does
this satisfy our criteria above for applying the Bernoulli equation? We're
implicitly assuming steady flow, and we haven't included any gravitational
field or viscosity model in our equations. What about incompressibility and
irrotationality?
Drop
the velocity field vector into the equations for divergence and curl, differentiate,
and we find:
Since
the divergence and curl of the velocity field are both zero, the flow is
incompressible and irrotational. The Bernoulli equation applies, and the flow
along any streamline has constant total pressure:
2) The Bernoulli equation describes this relationship under a certain set of conditions in which total pressure along any streamline is constant
3) This inviscid, irrotational, incompressible model predicts lift forces very well up to stall
4) It cannot predict drag due to the same assumptions and it cannot account for momentum loss in real flows
5) So, the circumstances in which we can use the Bernoulli equation to model airflow are useful but narrow and limited—be careful!

















Comments
Post a Comment